Advertisement

Federal Judge Overturns Durbin Rules, Debit Interchange up For Grabs Again

Aug. 1, 2013

The Durbin Amendment, a law capping debit interchange rates that has been in effect for nearly two years, was overturned yesterday by a federal judge in Washington. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Leon—calling the interchange fee and network non-exclusivity regulations under the Fed rules “fundamentally deficient”—ruled in favor of a group of retailers and trade organizations that had brought suit against the Federal Reserve Board on the matter in 2011. Judge Leon concluded in his order that the Fed “clearly disregarded Congress's statutory intent by inappropriately inflating all debit-card transaction fees by billions of dollars and [failed] to provide merchants with multiple unaffiliated networks for each debit-card transaction.”

Merchants, which widely hailed the Durbin Amendment when it was added to the Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform bill passed in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, became disenchanted with the law’s provisions after the final rule was implemented by the Fed. Many merchants—notably those that process a high volume of low-value transactions—actually saw the amount they pay in interchange rise when the card networks eliminated lower rates for small-ticket purchases.

The suit—filed more than a year ago by retailer groups including the National Retail Federation, the National Association of Convenience Stores and the National Restaurant Association—charged that the rules approved by the Fed Board of Governors exceed the authority granted to the Fed by Congress, and that the final rule is “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of process and otherwise not in accordance with the law in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.”

“From the very beginning, retailers and restaurants knew the Federal Reserve Board of Governors had grossly misapplied the Durbin Amendment,” said Mallory Duncan, senior vice president and general counsel of the National Retail Federation. “They failed to heed Congress’ call to set fee standards that were reasonable and proportional to the actual cost of a transaction. As a result, small-ticket transactions, such as those imposed on convenience stores and restaurants, skyrocketed under the misapplied law.”

Less than three months ago, the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond’s own economists confirmed the small-ticket phenomenon in an article about the law’s unintended consequences, bolstering Judge Leon’s decision that the Fed’s final rule did not follow the intent of Congress, which was to lower interchange for all categories of merchant.

The Richmond team’s economic research found “market-determined interchange fees tend to be too high compared with the social optimum, so [continuing to regulate] down interchange fees could be welfare enhancing.” But putting a cap on the maximum interchange fee may not be working the way lawmakers had hoped. “Capping the weighted average interchange fee, instead of the maximum interchange fee, may avoid the unintended consequence on small-ticket merchants.”

In the original motion, plaintiffs argued that the Fed’s final rule “greatly expanded the costs allowed in the interchange fee standard,” which resulted in “shifting billions of dollars in additional costs from the issuing banks to merchants that accept debit cards.” The suit also says the final rule mishandled the network non-exclusivity portion of the Durbin Amendment, resulting in “entire categories of debit card transactions—such as Internet and telephone transactions, hotel stays and car rentals—not being afforded the competitive network choice required by statute.”

Leon has dumped the matter back into the hands of the Fed, which will need to go through the lengthy rulemaking process again. In the interim, the judge said the current rules would remain in force, but that a new Final Rule would need to be formulated in “months, not years.”



Advertisement


  • Kmart Latest Breach Victim - Oct. 14, 2014

    Kmart Latest Breach VictimAfter a brief respite as the main target of hackers, a major retailer is in the news after experiencing a breach of its network security. Sears Holdings on Friday acknowledged the POS systems at an unknown number of Kmart stores have been compromised.

  • Two Companies, One Video? - Oct. 14, 2014

    Two Companies, One Video?Two startups trying to change the way consumers use payment cards launched with eerily similar marketing videos. CardNotPresent.com got to the bottom of the mystery.

  • MasterCard Mining Facebook In The Outback - Oct. 9, 2014

    MasterCard Mining Facebook In The OutbackMasterCard and Facebook have signed a two-year agreement in Australia that will give MasterCard access to anonymized Facebook user data the payment network will then offer to its financial institution clients to use for marketing purposes, according to published reports.

  • JP Morgan Chase Breach Could Be Largest Ever - Oct. 6, 2014
    JP Morgan Chase Breach Could Be Largest EverJP Morgan Chase, one of the largest financial institutions in the world and the largest issuer of credit cards in the U.S., disclosed in a securities filing on Thursday that its systems were hacked last summer potentially compromising the accounts of 76 million individuals and seven million businesses.
  • eBay Spins Off PayPal - Oct. 2, 2014
    eBay Spins Off PayPalOn Tuesday, eBay formally announced a move that had been expected, and agitated for by activist shareholders, for some time: PayPal will be spun off as its own independent, publicly traded company during the second half of 2015.
  • Fifth Third Launches Payments Division - Sept. 29, 2014

    Fifth Third Launches Payments DivisionCincinnati-based regional bank Fifth Third Bank, several years after spinning off its processing arm into the company that would become acquirer Vantiv, has thrown its hat back into the payments ring with the formation of a new Payments and Commerce Solutions division.

  • PayPal Opens Door to Bitcoin for Digital Merchants - Sept. 25, 2014

    PayPal Opens Door to Bitcoin for Digital MerchantsPayPal signed agreements with digital-currency processors BitPay, Coinbase and GoCoin so that PayPal merchants that sell digital goods can accept Bitcoin and process the transactions through one of those providers by integrating to them through the PayPal Payments Hub.

  • Home Depot Confirms Extent of Breach - Sept. 22, 2014
    Home Depot Confirms Extent of BreachOn Thursday, Atlanta-based do-it-yourself hardware chain Home Depot confirmed that the data breach it acknowledged on Sept. 8, which was first reported by security blogger Brian Krebs on Sept. 2, exposed the information of 56 million unique payment cards, officially making it the largest retail card breach ever reported, according to multiple sources.
  • Zooz Customers Tap into China with Alipay - Sept. 18, 2014
    Zooz Customers Tap into China with AlipayZooz, an Israeli payment service provider serving large enterprises, yesterday said it reached an agreement with Chinese online payment method Alipay that will enable its merchant clients to accept payments from Alipay's 300 million account holders.
  • Feedzai Partners with Azul for Faster Decisioning - Sept. 11, 2014

    Feedzai Partners with Azul for Faster DecisioningFeedzai, a Big-Data analytics company that provides antifraud technology, yesterday said it has partnered with Azul Systems to juice up its real-time data analysis enabling the company's solution to take more data into account when deciding if online transactions are fraudulent.

  • MCX Launches Long-Awaited Mobile Payment Pilots - Sept. 4, 2014
    MCX Launches Long-Awaited Mobile Payment Pilots MCX, the merchant-backed mobile payment solution that was announced about two years ago and has been shrouded in secrecy since, yesterday announced its mobile wallet and app would be available in several pilots over the rest of 2014 and roll out nationally in 2015.
  • Jumio, IDology Partner for Simpler ID Verification - Sept. 2, 2014
    Jumio, IDology Partner for Simpler ID VerificationJumio, a Silicon Valley-based online and mobile credentials management company, and identity-verification technology provider IDology, late last week unveiled a partnership that will enable companies to use government-issued photo IDs for verification purposes in card-not-present environments.

Advertisement

 

 

Sign Up Today Free

Receive the twice weekly CNP Report and monthly feature articles providing in-depth examinations of global CNP issues.

Please take a moment and register.
* First Name:

* Last Name:

* Password:

* Confirm Pwd:

* Email:

* Category:

Company:

 
Captcha
Answer:

 

 

CNP Archive

Researching companies or people in the CNP industry? Search our past coverage for targeted news and information.

Search here