Federal Judge Overturns Durbin Rules, Debit Interchange up For Grabs Again

Aug. 1, 2013

The Durbin Amendment, a law capping debit interchange rates that has been in effect for nearly two years, was overturned yesterday by a federal judge in Washington. U.S. District Court Judge Richard Leon—calling the interchange fee and network non-exclusivity regulations under the Fed rules “fundamentally deficient”—ruled in favor of a group of retailers and trade organizations that had brought suit against the Federal Reserve Board on the matter in 2011. Judge Leon concluded in his order that the Fed “clearly disregarded Congress's statutory intent by inappropriately inflating all debit-card transaction fees by billions of dollars and [failed] to provide merchants with multiple unaffiliated networks for each debit-card transaction.”

Merchants, which widely hailed the Durbin Amendment when it was added to the Dodd-Frank Wall Street reform bill passed in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, became disenchanted with the law’s provisions after the final rule was implemented by the Fed. Many merchants—notably those that process a high volume of low-value transactions—actually saw the amount they pay in interchange rise when the card networks eliminated lower rates for small-ticket purchases.

The suit—filed more than a year ago by retailer groups including the National Retail Federation, the National Association of Convenience Stores and the National Restaurant Association—charged that the rules approved by the Fed Board of Governors exceed the authority granted to the Fed by Congress, and that the final rule is “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of process and otherwise not in accordance with the law in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.”

“From the very beginning, retailers and restaurants knew the Federal Reserve Board of Governors had grossly misapplied the Durbin Amendment,” said Mallory Duncan, senior vice president and general counsel of the National Retail Federation. “They failed to heed Congress’ call to set fee standards that were reasonable and proportional to the actual cost of a transaction. As a result, small-ticket transactions, such as those imposed on convenience stores and restaurants, skyrocketed under the misapplied law.”

Less than three months ago, the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond’s own economists confirmed the small-ticket phenomenon in an article about the law’s unintended consequences, bolstering Judge Leon’s decision that the Fed’s final rule did not follow the intent of Congress, which was to lower interchange for all categories of merchant.

The Richmond team’s economic research found “market-determined interchange fees tend to be too high compared with the social optimum, so [continuing to regulate] down interchange fees could be welfare enhancing.” But putting a cap on the maximum interchange fee may not be working the way lawmakers had hoped. “Capping the weighted average interchange fee, instead of the maximum interchange fee, may avoid the unintended consequence on small-ticket merchants.”

In the original motion, plaintiffs argued that the Fed’s final rule “greatly expanded the costs allowed in the interchange fee standard,” which resulted in “shifting billions of dollars in additional costs from the issuing banks to merchants that accept debit cards.” The suit also says the final rule mishandled the network non-exclusivity portion of the Durbin Amendment, resulting in “entire categories of debit card transactions—such as Internet and telephone transactions, hotel stays and car rentals—not being afforded the competitive network choice required by statute.”

Leon has dumped the matter back into the hands of the Fed, which will need to go through the lengthy rulemaking process again. In the interim, the judge said the current rules would remain in force, but that a new Final Rule would need to be formulated in “months, not years.”


  • Data Breaches: Passwords and Baseball - June 18, 2015
    Data Breaches: Passwords and Baseball

    While the U.S. government continues to assess the damage done by the illegal intrusion of the networks of the Office of Personnel Management, two other hacks uncovered this week show the evolving nature of data breaches and the variety of information hackers are seeking.

  • Former NBA All Star Turns to CNP Fraud - June 1, 2015
    Former NBA All Star Turns to CNP Fraud

    Chris Gatling, a forward who played for eight different teams over an 11-year NBA career that included one All-Star Game appearance, was arrested in Scottsdale, Ariz. on Thursday and charged with fraud, aggravated identity theft and forgery.

  • CNP Expo: Adding Insult to Injury - May 21, 2015

    CNP Expo: Adding Insult to Injury

    Businesses often don't know how many orders they have declined in error, but a high number are false positives, according to panelists speaking to a packed session on the final day of the 2015 CNP Expo in Orlando, Fla.

  • CNP Expo: Should I Go With a PSP? - May 21, 2015
    CNP Expo: Should I Go With a 


    At a panel discussion on the last day of the 2015 CNP Expo in Orlando, Fla., several PSPs discussed considerations that need to be made when merchants are evaluating partners to assist in facilitating global payment acceptance.

  • CNP Expo: Mobile Payments in a CNP World - May 21, 2015
    CNP Expo: Mobile Payments in a CNP World

    Mobile payments are growing rapidly, but the proliferation of options can be overwhelming for merchants that want to offer the increasingly popular sales channel to their customers, according to panelists at a Thursday morning session at the 2015 CNP Expo in Orlando, Fla.

  • CNP Expo: Omnichallenge - May 21, 2015
    CNP Expo: Omnichallenge

    A seamless shopping experience is the goal for retailers who want to leverage the power of omnichannel commerce, but payments schemes are not easy to establish, even though shoppers have grown to expect everything to be easy, according to panelists at a session on the final day of the 2015 CNP Expo.

  • CNP Expo: Underbanked and Underappreciated - May 21, 2015
    CNP Expo: Underbanked and Underappreciated

    Shopping online without a credit card or bank account is possible, but difficult. And, a growing number of consumers either don’t qualify or don’t want these financial products, but online merchants still want to reach them.

  • 2015 CNP Award Winners Revealed - May 20, 2015
    2015 CNP Award Winners Revealed

    For the first time in its history, exactly half the CNP Awards handed out were presented to companies from outside the U.S., reinforcing the increasingly international nature of the card-not-present industry.

  • CNP Expo: Fraud on the Move - May 20, 2015
    CNP Expo: Fraud on the Move

    Justin McDonald, senior risk management consultant with The Fraud Practice, started a Wednesday afternoon discussion on mobile fraud by pointing out, "Mobile is convenient and immediate for customers, but fraudsters are taking advantage of that as well."

  • CNP Expo: Take Charge(Back) - May 20, 2015
    CNP Expo: Take Charge(Back)

    According to experts speaking at a Wednesday session of the CNP Expo in Orlando, chargebacks are the symptom of a bigger problem: not gathering enough information in the early stages of a transaction.

  • CNP Expo: Hostile Takeover - May 19, 2015
    CNP Expo: Hostile TakeoverPanelists at a Tuesday afternoon session of the 2015 CNP Expo said spoofing someone's identity in an effort to use their account represents 4.3 percent of all login attempts.
  • CNP Expo: Is This Seat Token? - May 19, 2015
    CNP Expo: Is This Seat Token?

    Rick Ricker, vice president of business development for enterprise solutions at 3Delta Systems, led a Tuesday-afternoon panel discussion examining how merchants choose and implement their tokenization technologies.

  • CNP Expo: EMV - What to Expect at Crunch Time - May 19, 2015
    CNP Expo: EMV – What to Expect at Crunch Time

    We all know EMV is coming, the question is, what should online merchants expect? Moderator Paul Tomasofsky, president of the Secure Remote Payment Council, began a panel at the CNP Expo Tuesday by reviewing the history of implementing EMV in other countries and discussing possible solutions for US merchants.

  • Starbucks: 'Not Hacked' but User Accounts Compromised - May 14, 2015
    Starbucks: ‘Not Hacked’ but User 

Accounts Compromised

    Starbucks says its popular mobile app has not been hacked, and that may be true, but a report by consumer reporter Bob Sullivan that fraudsters are specifically targeting the mobile app's users to drain their accounts then siphon off even more money when the auto-reload function kicks in appears to be accurate.

  • Mitek Solution Verifies Drivers' Licenses in Real Time - May 14, 2015
    Mitek Solution Verifies Drivers’ 

Licenses in Real Time

    Mitek, the company that first brought mobile check-capture technology to market, this week at a San Francisco technology event launched a solution companies can use to verify identities during account opening that authenticates a driver's license using the scanner of a mobile device.

  • Global EMV Adoption Still in Progress - May 12, 2015
    Global EMV Adoption Still in Progress

    Most of the world has a decade head start on the U.S. in the migration to the EMV standard, but developed regions are still adding hundreds of millions of chip cards years later, according to new data from EMVCo, suggesting the U.S. is in for a long ride.

  • SRPc Establishes Authentication Working Group - May 4, 2015
    SRPc Establishes Authentication Working Group

    The Secure Remote Payment Council (SRPc), a New Jersey-based trade association advocating for more secure online and mobile transactions, today established a working group that will investigate the state of consumer authentication for online payments and promote ideas on how it can be improved.




Sign Up Today Free

Receive the twice weekly CNP Report and monthly feature articles providing in-depth examinations of global CNP issues.

Please take a moment and register.
* First Name:

* Last Name:

* Password:

* Confirm Pwd:

* Email:

* Category:





CNP Archive

Researching companies or people in the CNP industry? Search our past coverage for targeted news and information.

Search here